← All posts
robotaxi

Opinion: Police Shouldn't Be Robotaxi Roadside Assistance. That's Why We're Building RAAS.

By David Alao · November 17, 2026 · 7 min read

robotaxiautonomous vehiclesWaymoTeslaRAASroadside assistanceopinion
Roof-mounted lidar and camera sensor array on a self-driving car, robotaxi roadside assistance

Last month a hotel guest in San Diego filmed something I haven't been able to stop thinking about. During the late-October king tides, several Waymo robotaxis crept into a flooded street, stopped, backed up and stopped again while human drivers went around them. At least one had a passenger inside. She stayed put until a police officer got in and drove the car through the water himself (The Auto Wire via Yahoo Autos, Nov. 4, 2026).

Think about that for a second. A trained, armed, sworn officer, paid by taxpayers, spent part of his shift working as a robotaxi's backup driver.

I'm not writing this to pile on Waymo. Honestly, the car did the cautious thing. My problem is with what happened next, because nobody had a plan for it.

Short answer: When a robotaxi breaks down, gets stuck or can't decide what to do, it usually stops and waits for remote help. If remote help can't fix it, a human has to show up in person to move it, tow it or look after the passenger. Right now that human is too often a police officer. That's a roadside assistance job, and it should go to roadside professionals.

What actually happened in San Diego?

The backstory makes the stall make sense. In May, Waymo filed a safety recall with NHTSA after an empty Waymo drove into an "untraversable flooded section" of a 40-mph road on April 20. The recall covers 3,791 vehicles. The interim fix doesn't teach the cars to judge water depth. It limits where and when they drive so they're less likely to meet a flooded road at all (The Auto Wire).

SUV driving through deep floodwater on a city street
Floodwater can stall any vehicle, driverless or not. Photo: Aldward Castillo / Unsplash

So in San Diego the cars saw water and refused to go in. Good. But when this kind of system decides it can't go on safely, its fallback is to stop. On a street filling with seawater, a stopped car turns into a roadblock with a person sitting inside.

A human driver in the same spot would back out, follow someone through the shallow side, or turn around in a driveway. The robotaxi apparently couldn't find another option it trusted, and nobody could fix it from a screen somewhere. Someone had to physically get in. That someone was a cop.

Is this just one bad week for robotaxis?

No. In the same stretch of news:

  • NHTSA opened a recall query into Waymo on November 6, after finding that most of the reported incidents of Waymos illegally passing stopped school buses happened after the software update meant to fix it. Waymo says it has made "significant improvements" and hasn't received a citation since March 2026 (TechCrunch, Nov. 9, 2026).
  • Tesla launched robotaxi service in San Antonio on November 9, adding to Austin, Dallas, Fort Worth, Houston, Miami and Orlando. The same report notes that Waymo only recently restarted service in San Antonio after a five-month pause, following incidents where its vehicles got stuck after driving into flooded roads (TechCrunch, Nov. 9, 2026).
  • Waymo started fully driverless service in San Diego, Denver, Las Vegas and Tampa this summer, per The Auto Wire. Denver means snow. Tampa means hurricanes. San Diego means king tides on a published calendar.

The pattern is clear. These fleets are growing city by city, the software is getting better, and the edge cases aren't going away. When software can't solve the problem, the vehicle stops, and somebody has to come.

What happens when a robotaxi breaks down?

From what's been reported publicly, the answer today is messy. The company usually tries remote assistance first. If that fails, it may send its own field staff, call a tow company, or wait. In the meantime, the car sits in a lane, and the people closest to it are the public and whoever answers 911.

California is at least trying to make this cleaner. Since July 1, under AB 1777, officers can issue a "notice of autonomous vehicle noncompliance" straight to the company, and AV operators have to provide two-way communication with first responders and a dedicated phone line (The Auto Wire). That's a step forward. But a phone line still means an officer standing next to a frozen car, on hold, while traffic backs up. In San Diego, the quickest fix was still for the officer to drive it himself.

Why shouldn't police handle stalled driverless cars?

Because they have more important work, and every minute spent babysitting a stuck vehicle is a minute not spent on it.

Close-up of a police car's light bar glowing blue
Every hour an officer spends babysitting a stalled robotaxi is an hour away from other calls. Photo: Max Fleischmann / Unsplash

An officer directing traffic around a stalled robotaxi isn't responding to a domestic call. An officer climbing into a flooded car to move it isn't at a crash scene where someone is hurt. I have enormous respect for what police do. I just don't think their job description should include "fleet recovery for a tech company."

We already solved this problem for human drivers decades ago. When your car breaks down, you don't call the police to fix it. You call a tow truck, a mobile mechanic, a locksmith. There's a whole profession built around getting stuck vehicles moving again. Autonomous fleets need the same thing, wired in from day one rather than improvised by whoever shows up.

So who should respond when a robotaxi gets stuck?

A roadside professional, dispatched automatically, in minutes.

That's what we're building at Road Ally with RAAS: Roadside Assistance as a Service. It's an API. Instead of a robotaxi sitting in floodwater while someone at headquarters figures out who to call, the vehicle or fleet system calls the API itself the moment it needs help: a fault, a recovery, a passenger who needs a hand. Our dispatch network matches the closest qualified Ally, sends live status and ETA back to the fleet's operations centre, and closes the job with a structured record: timestamps, what was done, proof of service (Road Ally Partners).

The bigger idea is simple. Roadside assistance shouldn't be a membership card in a glovebox. It should be infrastructure. Insurers, dealers, EV makers and autonomous fleets can plug into it, so any vehicle, human-driven or autonomous, gets help in minutes instead of hours.

We already run that infrastructure every day for people. Road Ally works 24/7, with Allies in 158 cities across Canada and the US, an average response under 30 minutes, and a 4.9-star rating from the drivers we've helped. RAAS exposes the same verification, routing and dispatch stack to partners.

Does Road Ally have autonomous vehicle specialists today?

I want to be straight about this, because the AV industry has had enough overpromising.

We're signing specialist Allies now: experienced tow operators, recovery pros and technicians. When the time is right, we'll send some of them through dedicated EV and AV training so they can secure a driverless vehicle, isolate high-voltage systems safely, and look after passengers. That training is ahead of us, not behind us. The RAAS API itself is in active development, and we're working with a small group of design partners to shape it.

What I can tell you is that the problem is real today, and it's growing faster than anyone planned for. Somebody needs to own it. It shouldn't be the police.

What happens when robotaxis come north?

Here's the part I keep coming back to. San Diego king tides are mild compared to what's coming. Picture a driverless fleet in a Chicago lake-effect squall, a Montreal snow-loading night, or a Winnipeg morning at -35°C with a dead 12-volt battery. The cars will stop, because stopping is the safe default. Then who comes?

If the answer is still "whoever's on patrol," cities are going to get frustrated fast, and so will riders sitting in a car that won't move. If the answer is "a verified roadside pro, dispatched by the vehicle itself, on site in minutes," then autonomy actually works the way it was promised.

That problem only gets bigger as more driverless vehicles take the road. Waymo and Tesla are already adding cities. More cars means more chances for one to stall, block a lane, and pull a police officer or a firefighter off a call that can't wait.

Giving fleets a dedicated roadside layer through the RAAS API is how we keep that from becoming routine. I believe getting this right helps keep the roads safer for the people in those cars and everyone sharing the street with them.

A note to fleets, insurers and carmakers

If you run an autonomous or EV program and you're tired of improvising recoveries, talk to us. We're onboarding design partners for RAAS now. Register your interest on the Partners page or email partners@roadally.co with your company, use case and timeline.

And if you're a tow operator or recovery specialist who wants to be part of this from the start, become an Ally. We're signing the people who'll do this work.

Police should be free to save lives and fight crime. Let us handle the cars.

David Alao is the founder of Road Ally.

FAQ

What happens when a Waymo or other robotaxi gets stuck?

It usually stops and asks for remote assistance. If that can't fix the problem, someone has to come in person to move or tow it and help any passenger. In San Diego's October 2026 king tides, a police officer had to drive a stalled Waymo out of floodwater.

Who is responsible for towing a driverless car?

The fleet operator is responsible for recovering its vehicles. In practice, police and first responders often end up dealing with a stalled robotaxi first because it's blocking traffic. California's AB 1777 now requires AV companies to give first responders two-way communication and a dedicated phone line.

What is RAAS (Roadside Assistance as a Service)?

RAAS is an API Road Ally is building so insurers, dealers, EV makers and autonomous fleets can request roadside help directly from their own systems. The API dispatches the nearest qualified Ally and returns live status and a structured completion record.

Why is NHTSA investigating Waymo?

On November 6, 2026, NHTSA opened a recall query after finding that most reported cases of Waymos illegally passing stopped school buses happened after a software fix that was supposed to solve the problem. Waymo says it has made significant improvements.

Does Road Ally have AV-trained roadside technicians?

Not yet. Road Ally is signing specialist Allies now and plans to send some for dedicated EV and autonomous vehicle training when the time is right. The RAAS API is in active development with design partners.

Don’t Wait Until You’re Stranded

Download Road Ally now and have instant access to vetted, nearby help the moment something goes wrong. No subscription. No call limits. Just help when you need it.